What is the biological species concept? Its merits and demerits

The biological species concept (BSC) is a widely used definition of a species in biology. This concept defines a species as a group of organisms that can interbreed and produce viable offspring. The BSC was proposed by Ernst Mayr in 1942 and has been used extensively in the study of speciation and evolutionary biology. In this class note, we will explore the merits and demerits of the biological species concept.

Merits of the Biological Species Concept

  1. The BSC provides a clear and objective definition of a species. It is based on the biological properties of organisms, such as their ability to interbreed and produce viable offspring, rather than on external features, such as morphology or behavior. This allows for more precise and consistent identification and definition of species.
  2. The BSC emphasizes the importance of reproductive isolation in the formation and maintenance of species. It recognizes that gene flow between populations is an essential factor in evolutionary change and that the development of reproductive isolation is a critical component of the speciation process.
  3. The BSC is widely used in biological research and has been applied to many different groups of organisms, from bacteria to plants and animals. Its broad applicability makes it a helpful tool for studying the diversity of life on Earth.

Demerits of Biological Species Concept

  1. The BSC may not be applicable to all organisms. There are many cases where organisms that are considered distinct species under the BSC can interbreed and produce viable offspring. This can occur in cases where hybridization is common, such as in plants or in some groups of animals, and can complicate the application of the BSC.
  2. The BSC does not take into account asexual reproduction, which is common in many groups of organisms, such as bacteria, fungi, and some plants. In these organisms, interbreeding and reproductive isolation are not applicable, making the BSC unsuitable for defining species in these groups.
  3. The BSC can be difficult to apply in cases where there is limited or incomplete information about the biology of a particular group of organisms. In some cases, it may not be possible to determine whether two populations can interbreed and produce viable offspring, making applying the BSC in these cases challenging.

The biological species concept is a widely used and influential concept in the study of speciation and evolutionary biology. While it has many merits, including its clarity and emphasis on reproductive isolation, it also has its demerits, limited applicability in some groups of organisms, and potential difficulty in application. As with any scientific concept, the BSC is a tool for understanding the diversity of life on Earth. Its limitations must be considered in the context of the organisms being studied.